Executive Compensation Planning: RSUs vs. Stock Options – Which Reigns Supreme?

As financial advisors at Tenet Wealth Partners, we often encounter executives grappling with the complexities of their compensation packages. One of the most common dilemmas we see is the choice between Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) and Stock Options. Both can be powerful wealth-building tools, but understanding their nuances is crucial for making informed decisions. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the world of executive compensation, exploring the ins and outs of RSUs and Stock Options, and help you navigate the path to financial success.

Understanding RSUs (Restricted Stock Units)

Restricted Stock Units, or RSUs, have become increasingly popular in executive compensation packages over the past decade. But what exactly are they? Think of RSUs as a promise from your company to give you shares of stock in the future, subject to certain conditions – typically, staying with the company for a specified period.

Here’s how RSUs typically work:

1. Grant: Your company grants you a certain number of RSUs.
2. Vesting: Over time, these RSUs “vest” according to a predetermined schedule.
3. Delivery: Once vested, the actual shares of stock are delivered to you.
4. Taxation: You’re taxed on the value of the shares at the time of vesting.

One of the key advantages of RSUs is their simplicity. Unlike stock options, which we’ll discuss later, RSUs always have value as long as the company’s stock price is above zero. This provides a level of certainty that many executives find appealing.

Exploring Stock Options

Stock options, on the other hand, give you the right to purchase company stock at a predetermined price (known as the strike price or exercise price) within a specific timeframe. There are two main types of stock options:

1. Incentive Stock Options (ISOs): These are only available to employees and offer potential tax advantages.
2. Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs): These can be granted to non-employees and have different tax implications.

The lifecycle of a stock option typically looks like this:

1. Grant: You’re given the option to buy a certain number of shares at a specific price.
2. Vesting: Like RSUs, options usually vest over time.
3. Exercise: You choose to buy the shares at the strike price.
4. Sell: You can then sell the shares at the current market price.

The potential for significant gains with stock options can be enticing. If the market price of the stock rises well above your strike price, you could see substantial profits. However, this comes with increased risk – if the stock price falls below your strike price, your options could become worthless.

Key Differences Between RSUs and Stock Options

While both RSUs and stock options are forms of equity compensation, they differ in several crucial ways:

1. Value at Grant: RSUs always have value, while stock options only have value if the stock price exceeds the strike price.
2. Upside Potential: Stock options offer potentially unlimited upside, while the value of RSUs is directly tied to the stock price.
3. Downside Risk: RSUs retain some value even if the stock price drops, while options can become worthless.
4. Complexity: RSUs are generally simpler to understand and manage compared to stock options.
5. Voting Rights: RSU holders typically don’t have voting rights until the shares are delivered, while option holders never have voting rights until they exercise their options and receive actual shares.

Tax Implications of RSUs and Stock Options

Understanding the tax implications of your equity compensation is crucial for effective financial planning. Let’s break it down.

RSU Taxation:

• RSUs are taxed as ordinary income when they vest.
• The entire value of the vested shares is subject to income tax and payroll taxes.
• Any subsequent appreciation is taxed as capital gains when you sell the shares.

Stock Option Taxation:

• For NSOs, you’re taxed at exercise on the difference between the strike price and the market price (known as the “spread”).
• For ISOs, you’re not taxed at exercise unless you trigger the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT).
• When you sell the shares, you may be eligible for long-term capital gains treatment if you meet certain holding requirements.

It’s important to note that the tax implications can be complex, especially with ISOs and the potential AMT impact. We always recommend consulting with a tax professional to understand your specific situation.

Pros and Cons of RSUs

Pros:

• Guaranteed Value: RSUs always have value as long as the company’s stock has value.
• Simplicity: Easier to understand and manage compared to options.
• Less Downside Risk: Even if the stock price drops, RSUs retain some value.

Cons:

• Limited Upside: The potential for outsized gains is less than with options.
• Tax Timing: You’re taxed at vesting, even if you don’t sell the shares.
• Less Flexibility: You can’t control the timing of the taxable event as you can with options.

Pros and Cons of Stock Options

Pros:

• Upside Potential: Possibility for significant gains if the stock price rises substantially.
• Tax Flexibility: With options, you can often control when you recognize income.
• Motivation: Options can provide a strong incentive for employees to drive company performance.

Cons:

• Risk of Expiration: Options can expire worthless if the stock price doesn’t exceed the strike price.
• Complexity: Options can be more challenging to understand and manage.
• Potential for Large Tax Bills: Exercising options can result in significant tax liabilities, especially with NSOs.

Choosing Between RSUs and Stock Options

When it comes to choosing between RSUs and stock options, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on various factors, including your risk tolerance, financial goals, and overall financial situation. Here are some considerations:

1. Risk Tolerance: If you’re risk-averse, RSUs might be more appealing due to their guaranteed value. If you’re comfortable with more risk and potential reward, options might be a better fit.
2. Company Outlook: If you’re bullish on your company’s future, options could provide more upside. If you’re less certain, RSUs offer more security.
3. Cash Flow Needs: RSUs provide more predictable income, while options require careful planning around exercise and potential tax liabilities.
4. Career Stage: Early in your career, you might be more willing to take risks with options. As you approach retirement, the certainty of RSUs might be more attractive.
5. Overall Compensation Package: Consider how equity compensation fits into your total compensation and financial plan.

Making Informed Decisions for Executive Compensation Planning

Navigating the world of executive compensation can be complex, but understanding the nuances of RSUs and stock options is crucial for making informed decisions. At Tenet Wealth Partners, we believe that the key to successful executive compensation planning lies in aligning your equity compensation with your overall financial goals and risk tolerance.

Remember, there’s no universal “best” choice between RSUs and stock options. The right decision depends on your individual circumstances, financial objectives, and comfort with risk. It’s also worth noting that many executive compensation packages include a mix of both RSUs and options, allowing for a balanced approach.

As you consider your equity compensation, here are some final thoughts:

1. Look at the Big Picture: Consider how your equity compensation fits into your overall financial plan and long-term goals.
2. Stay Informed: Keep up with changes in tax laws and company policies that might affect your equity compensation.
3. Plan for Taxes: Develop a strategy to manage the tax implications of your equity compensation, potentially spreading out taxable events over multiple years.
4. Diversify: Don’t put all your eggs in one basket. Consider strategies to diversify your portfolio beyond your company stock.
5. Regularly Review: As your career progresses and your financial situation changes, regularly review and adjust your equity compensation strategy.
6. Seek Professional Advice: Given the complexities of executive compensation, it’s often beneficial to work with financial advisors and tax professionals who specialize in this area.

At Tenet Wealth Partners, we’ve seen firsthand how proper planning around executive compensation can make a significant difference in our clients’ financial lives. Whether you’re leaning towards RSUs for their certainty, attracted to stock options for their upside potential, or considering a mix of both, the key is to make these decisions as part of a comprehensive financial plan.

Remember, your equity compensation is more than just a perk – it’s a powerful tool for building long-term wealth. By understanding the nuances of RSUs and stock options, and making informed decisions about your executive compensation, you’re taking a crucial step towards securing your financial future. Here’s to your success, both in the boardroom and in your personal finances!

Registered Representative of Sanctuary Securities Inc. and Investment Advisor Representative of Sanctuary Advisors, LLC. Securities offered through Sanctuary Securities, Inc., Member FINRA, SIPC. Advisory services offered through Sanctuary Advisors, LLC., a SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Tenet Wealth Partners is a DBA of Sanctuary Securities, Inc. and Sanctuary Advisors, LLC.

The information provided in this communication was sourced by Tenet Wealth Partners through public information and public channels and is in no way proprietary to Tenet Wealth Partners, nor is the information provided Tenet Wealth Partner’s position, recommendation or investment advice.

This material is provided for informational/educational purposes only. This material is not intended to constitute legal, tax, investment or financial advice. Tenet Wealth Partners does not offer tax advice and you should consult with a tax professional for your specific situation.  Investments are subject to risk, including but not limited to market and interest rate fluctuations.

Any performance data represents past performance which is no guarantee of future results. Prices/yields/figures mentioned herein are as of the date noted unless indicated otherwise. All figures subject to market fluctuation and change. Additional information available upon request.